Real Madrid’s first defeat of the season against Real Betis has sparked debate over Jose Mourinho’s decision to substitute Arda Guler in the second half, bringing on Diamonde in his place. Despite Guler being arguably the best player on the pitch for the visitors, the substitution raised eyebrows. According to Spanish outlet AS, Mourinho acknowledged that the decision was not easy, admitting it might have seemed unfair. The Portuguese coach explained that he feared Guler could receive a second yellow card, as Betis players were targeting him. However, this explanation only partially masks the underlying complexities of managing a star-studded squad.
Guler’s Performance vs. Substitution Logic
In the match against Betis, Guler was a creative force, creating seven chances and recovering five balls, making him the most productive attacking player for Real Madrid. His defensive work rate was equally impressive. Yet, his teammates, including Kylian Mbappe, failed to capitalize on his efforts. Mourinho’s decision to replace him with Diamonde, the club’s record signing at €125 million, seemed more about managing squad dynamics than on-field performance.
The Pattern of Substitutions
This was not an isolated incident. In the previous match against Espanyol in Barcelona, Guler was substituted after an hour, despite providing an assist for Jude Bellingham. In both cases, Guler was among the best players, yet he was the one taken off. Mourinho’s choices reflect a broader strategy to balance the needs of high-profile players like Mbappe and Vinicius Junior, who are expected to play regularly.
The Vinicius Factor and Squad Management
Vinicius Junior presents a unique challenge. Attempts to rest him last season, led by Xabi Alonso, were met with resistance, as the Brazilian wants to play every match. Mourinho has to navigate these egos while ensuring results. In the Betis match, Vinicius was involved in key moments, including a disallowed goal and winning a penalty that Mbappe missed. His contributions, though not always decisive, make him difficult to bench.
Guler’s Role and Future
Despite the substitutions, Guler remains a starter in a ‘false right winger’ role. He continues to seize every opportunity, even when teammates are not on his wavelength. The looming threat of Diamonde, given his hefty price tag, adds pressure. Guler is confident that working under Mourinho this season will aid his development, and he aims to prove his worth whenever given the chance. The coming months will reveal whether Mourinho can balance these competing demands without alienating one of his most promising talents.